California Exit Tax & Wealth Tax: What is it & How it Applies to You

Website Banner 3

Key Takeaways

  • So, what is the California exit tax? The California exit tax explained:
  • How much is the California exit tax?
  • Who has to pay California exit tax?
  • Why was the California exit tax of 2020 created?
  • The California Wealth Tax Proposal in a Nutshell

California is known for having some of the most significant in-state taxes in the country with a 13.3% annual income tax rate.

However, did you know that you might still be taxed even after you leave the state?

Yep! Thanks to the California exit tax legislation, depending on how much money you get from in-state activities, such as investments in real estate or business operations, you could still be treated like a Californian on your next tax return!

Join us as we walk you through the California wealth and exit tax questions, such as “what is the exit tax in california,” how much it is, who it applies to, and a deeper dive into the CA wealth tax proposal and the Assembly Bill 2088.

Read more

Bankruptcy and Automatic Stay

Debt

According to United States bankruptcy law, an automatic stay is defined as an automatic injunction, the purpose of which halts the actions of creditors to collect debts from a debtor who has filed for bankruptcy relief.

Key Takeaways

  • Provisions for automatic stay fall under section 362 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code, which suggests that the stay begins automatically when the debtor files a petition with the bankruptcy court.
  • Although a stay is automatic, secured creditors may file a petition with the bankruptcy court for relief against the automatic stay if they can show cause.
  • The automatic stay protects the debtor against certain actions of the creditor which may include judicial proceedings, actions to obtain the debtor’s property, actions to enforce a lien against the debtor’s property, and set-off indebtedness.

Provisions for automatic stay fall under section 362 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code, which suggests that the stay begins automatically when the debtor files a petition with the bankruptcy court.

Although a stay is automatic, secured creditors may file a petition with the bankruptcy court for relief against the automatic stay if they can show cause.

Read more

The Differences Between the Federal System and the State of California

The Differences Between the Federal System and the State of California

Key Takeaways

  • Internal Revenue Service
  • State of California
  • Representation You Can Count on

As a small business owner, you are used to dealing with the IRS and the state. You file income taxes with the IRS every year and file returns with the state when they are due. Paying tax is paying tax, right? So, why is there such a difference between the way the IRS plays versus the state?

Read more

Can Currently Non-Collectible (CNC) Status Stop the FTB?

CNC Status

Key Takeaways

  • The decision to place a taxpayer’s account on CNC is based on an examination of your Collection Information Statement (CIS) that has been completely updated to the time of the examination.
  • Currently Not Collectible status is meant for severe economic hardship – it is not easily granted.
  • Periodically, the IRS and FTB will re-evaluate your situation to see if your financial status has changed enough to begin collections again.

Sometimes your financial fortunes take a turn for the worse, and you find yourself owing back taxes to the Franchise Tax Board. You don’t even have two coins to rub together, much less make installment payments, yet you are looking for an alternative to filing for bankruptcy. An Offer in Compromise is also off the table; you just don’t have the money.

Read more

Your Rights as a California Taxpayer

SalesTaxCARightsBlog Scaled

Key Takeaways

  • The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) administers the tax program for both business and property taxes for the State of California.
  • Sales and use tax
    Fuel tax
    Cigarette tax
    Alcoholic beverage tax

    Business taxpayers may take up their concerns directly with the main office of the CDTFA while property tax concerns are addressed by the local county office.

  • When you deal with the tax agencies of California, you may feel like you do not have any rights.

The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) administers the tax program for both business and property taxes for the State of California. Business taxes include:

Read more

Taxes and Bankruptcy

VideoBG222

Some income taxes can be discharged in bankruptcy — but the rules are specific, and most people are surprised by how narrow the qualifying window actually is.

Bankruptcy is not a blanket solution for tax debt. Whether your taxes survive or get wiped out depends on which taxes are involved, when the returns were filed, when the IRS assessed the liability, and a few other conditions that have to be met simultaneously. Get them all right, and the tax is gone. Miss one, and it survives the bankruptcy as if you never filed.

The Three-Year, Two-Year, and 240-Day Rules

To discharge income taxes in bankruptcy, three timing conditions must all be satisfied at once.

The three-year rule: the tax return for the year in question must have been due at least three years before you file your bankruptcy petition. So for tax year 2020 — with a return due April 15, 2021 — the earliest a Chapter 7 petition could potentially discharge that liability is April 2024. If you file bankruptcy in February 2024, the 2020 tax debt is not eligible.

The two-year rule: you must have actually filed the return at least two years before the bankruptcy petition. Filing late doesn’t disqualify you outright, but it does push the discharge window further out. If you filed your 2020 return in October 2022, the two-year clock runs from October 2022, not from the original April 2021 due date.

The 240-day rule: the IRS must have assessed the tax at least 240 days before your bankruptcy filing. Assessment usually happens when the IRS processes your return, but it can also result from an audit, an amended return, or a CP2000 notice. If the IRS assessed additional tax from a 2020 audit in January 2024, that assessment doesn’t become eligible for discharge until September 2024.

Taxes That Cannot Be Discharged Regardless of Timing

Several categories of tax debt are non-dischargeable no matter how old they are.

Payroll trust fund taxes — the portion of employee withholding that an employer holds in trust and remits to the IRS — are non-dischargeable under 11 U.S.C. § 507(a)(8). The IRS treats these as money that never belonged to the employer in the first place. If you owe a Trust Fund Recovery Penalty (Form 4183) as a responsible party of a business, that liability follows you through bankruptcy.

Taxes related to fraud or willful tax evasion are also non-dischargeable. If the liability arose because you filed a fraudulent return or deliberately evaded tax, bankruptcy doesn’t help. The same applies to taxes on returns that were never filed at all — the IRS files a substitute return on your behalf, but that is not treated as a return you filed for discharge purposes. You generally have to file the actual return yourself, and it has to be filed before the bankruptcy petition.

Chapter 7 vs. Chapter 13 for Tax Debt

Chapter 7 can fully discharge qualifying income taxes; Chapter 13 puts non-qualifying taxes into a repayment plan, often without additional penalties accruing during the plan.

In a Chapter 7 case, taxes that pass all the timing tests and the fraud/willfulness tests become non-priority unsecured claims and are discharged along with credit card debt and medical bills. There is no repayment — the liability is gone.

Chapter 13 is more useful when some taxes qualify and others don’t, or when you have assets you want to keep. Priority tax claims — the ones that don’t pass the tests — get paid through the Chapter 13 plan over three to five years. The advantage is that the IRS generally cannot accrue additional interest or penalties on those claims while the plan is active. For someone with a large payroll tax liability or recent income taxes, Chapter 13 can reduce the total cost even without achieving a full discharge.

What Happens to a Federal Tax Lien

Discharging the underlying tax debt does not automatically remove a filed federal tax lien.

The discharge eliminates your personal obligation to pay — what lawyers call the in-personam liability. But if the IRS filed a Notice of Federal Tax Lien before your bankruptcy petition, that lien is a secured interest in your property. It stays attached to assets you owned at the time of the bankruptcy, even after the discharge. To remove the lien, you typically need to either pay the secured portion or ask the bankruptcy court to avoid the lien through an adversary proceeding.

This distinction catches people off guard. They complete the bankruptcy, assume the tax debt is gone, and then find the lien on their property when they try to sell or refinance. Check the county recorder’s records and pull an IRS transcript before assuming the lien isn’t a factor.

This Requires Both a Bankruptcy Attorney and a Tax Attorney

The tax discharge analysis and the bankruptcy filing are two separate disciplines, and most general bankruptcy attorneys don’t do the tax side carefully.

The discharge eligibility rules — especially the tolling provisions, which can pause and extend all three timing periods based on prior bankruptcy filings, pending Offers in Compromise, or Collection Due Process hearings — require someone who understands both bodies of law. A bankruptcy attorney can file the petition. A tax attorney needs to verify whether the taxes actually qualify before you do.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you discharge IRS debt in Chapter 7 bankruptcy?

Yes, but only income taxes that meet the three-year rule (return due at least 3 years before filing), the two-year rule (return actually filed at least 2 years before filing), and the 240-day assessment rule — and only if the return wasn’t fraudulent and the tax wasn’t willfully evaded. Payroll taxes, recent income taxes, and taxes on unfiled returns do not qualify.

Does filing bankruptcy stop IRS collections?

Yes. Filing any bankruptcy chapter triggers an automatic stay under 11 U.S.C. § 362, which immediately halts most IRS collection activity — notices, levies, garnishments. The stay lasts for the duration of the bankruptcy case. The IRS can request relief from the stay in limited circumstances, but it typically does not pursue collection while the stay is in effect.

What happens to a tax lien after bankruptcy?

The discharge wipes out your personal liability for the tax, but a previously filed Notice of Federal Tax Lien survives and remains attached to property you owned before the bankruptcy. To clear the lien from property, you either pay the secured value or seek lien avoidance through the bankruptcy court. The lien does not extend to property you acquire after the petition date.

If you’re weighing bankruptcy against other options for resolving tax debt, the five-part discharge eligibility test walks through the specific conditions in more detail — or see our overview of other options for resolving tax debt if bankruptcy isn’t the right fit. Book a free 15-minute call if you want to talk through which approach makes sense for your situation.

Have a Tax Question or Notice?

If you’re dealing with an IRS audit, collection action, California state tax matter, or any other tax issue, we can review your situation in a free 15-minute consultation.

Schedule a Free Call →    Or call: (619) 378-3138

Differences Between the Federal Tax System and the California State Tax System

VideoBG217

Key Takeaways

  • Briefly I want to talk to you about differences between the federal tax system and the state tax system.
  • Most FTV actions are initiated from the Sacramento office whether they are levis, phone calls, contacts with tax payers, or any sort of collection actions.
  • The states have limited resources at the local level.


Briefly I want to talk to you about differences between the federal tax system and the state tax system. As I mentioned, due to limited resources state are usually more aggressive in their collection tactics and their examination tactics than the federal government and the principal reason for this is because taxation for the states is the principal source of revenue racing. A lot of times when there is a budget shortfall the state will lean on their self tax and the federal tax bureau will lean on the income tax to help mandate collections priorities and help raise revenues either through collecting past due liabilities or examining returns and finding new ones. In general, the states because of their limited resources will rely more on in voluntary collections actions than field representatives so there’s much greater reliance at the state level for collections processes that are instituted from a remote location so for example in California the main center of operation for the FTV which is the Franchise Tax for the State of California income tax bureau is in Sacramento. Most FTV actions are initiated from the Sacramento office whether they are levis, phone calls, contacts with tax payers, or any sort of collection actions. The states have limited resources at the local level.

Read more

California State Specific Tax Issues

VideoBG216

Key Takeaways

  • So now I’d like to talk to you about some issues with regarding that the states have specifically.
  • In California, we have a number of challenges in dealing with the state taxis that are either less of an issue or non-existent at federal level.
  • The first as I’ve kind of touched down earlier is overside.


So now I’d like to talk to you about some issues with regarding that the states have specifically. In California, we have a number of challenges in dealing with the state taxis that are either less of an issue or non-existent at federal level. The first as I’ve kind of touched down earlier is overside. There is usually less overside on cases than there is at the federal level. And I mean by that, is the auditor or the collection agent is given a lot more latitude in most cases to handle the cases as they see fit as long as it falls within the administrative guidelines. This particularly has an impact on the examinations process so a lot of the times the auditors are kind of given free rein to define the scope of what the audit is in sales tax or in particular they can do a really detail investigation and go through a number steps that you may not find in the federal process. As a result of this and as a result of the states having fewer resources, there is often times administrative delay when dealing with the state cases. For example, the time frame in California right now is if I were to represent a client in a sales tax audit and me and the auditor just agreed on the result and I filed and appeal, it would take anywhere from 8 to 12 months under the current structure to hear that appeal.

Read more

California Collection Tools Part One – Voluntary Compliance

VideoBG215

Key Takeaways

  • So, the first thing I’d like to talk about is I’d like to talk about some of the collection tools that the state uses to enforce collection against tax payers.
  • The state operates very much like the federal government.
  • It resorts to voluntary compliance whenever possible and uses involuntary compliance measures is kind of a step for dealing with tax payers that are not complying with what the states priorities are.


So, the first thing I’d like to talk about is I’d like to talk about some of the collection tools that the state uses to enforce collection against tax payers. The state operates very much like the federal government. It resorts to voluntary compliance whenever possible and uses involuntary compliance measures is kind of a step for dealing with tax payers that are not complying with what the states priorities are. In the case of California, the state will use voluntary compliance measures like letters to encourage tax payers contact, collection agents to Sacramento reach out to tax payers through phone calls, occasionally utilizing the local office to conduct field visits when they feel as appropriate and then try and encourage some sort of resolution of the tax account at hand. So, resolution from a state perspective means that all returns are filed and paid on time and in cases where there are missing returns they want the tax payer to file them. In cases where the tax payer hasn’t paid their balance then they want the tax payer to enter them to a satisfactory payment arrangement. Payment arrangements at the state level are a little stricter than they are at the federal level. As I mentioned, the tax payer doesn’t have the same set of rights that they do at the federal level so the state is generally more aggressive towards revenue collection than you will find at the federal level.

Have a Tax Question or Notice?

If you’re dealing with an IRS audit, collection action, California state tax matter, or any other tax issue, we can review your situation in a free 15-minute consultation.

Schedule a Free Call →    Or call: (619) 378-3138

California Collection Tools Part Two – Involuntary Compliance

VideoBG214

Key Takeaways

  • Topic: California Collection Tools Part Two – Involuntary Compliance
  • Warrants or seizures of property and levies are actions taken against bank accounts and things like that..


On the involuntary side of things when the tax payer does not get in the compliance or refuses to pay the state can do a number of negative actions so it means against any personal real property or common, earnings withholding orders, garnishments against wages are another common thing and finally, levies and warrants. Warrants or seizures of property and levies are actions taken against bank accounts and things like that.

Brotman Law Featured in Inc. Magazine - Fastest Growing Law Firm in California